Ice Cream Culture at the Jersey Shore
Few things say summer in Toms River quite like an ice cream cone on a warm evening. After a day at nearby Island Beach State Park, a boat ride on Barnegat Bay, or a Little League game in a town famous for its 1998 world championship, families often end the day with a frozen treat. The Jersey Shore has a deep-rooted love for soft serve, frozen custard, and Italian ice, traditions that stretch back generations along the boardwalks.
Today, residents enjoy ice cream in many forms: scoop shops, drive-through soft serve stands, grocery store pints, and frozen novelties stocked in home freezers. The brands on this list are widely available in and around Toms River, through dedicated shops or local supermarkets, and each brings something different to the table.
How We Ranked These Brands
We considered flavor quality, texture, ingredient standards, variety, availability in the Toms River area, value, and the overall experience each brand delivers, whether enjoyed at a shop or at home.
Our Top 10 Picks
Here are the ten standout choices, each selected for its reputation, quality, and value to people in Toms River.
1. Rita's Italian Ice & Frozen Custard
Rita's is a true summertime institution in New Jersey. Its Italian ice is made fresh daily in a wide range of fruity and creamy flavors, and its signature Gelati layers ice with smooth frozen custard. The tradition of free ice on the first day of spring signals the start of the season for many local families, and its walk-up stands are a familiar sight on summer nights.
2. Ben & Jerry's
Ben & Jerry's is famous for chunky, creative flavors packed with cookie dough, brownies, and swirls. Its pints are a supermarket favorite across Ocean County, and the brand is known for its social mission and commitment to responsibly sourced ingredients. Flavors such as Half Baked and Cherry Garcia have become modern classics that appeal to adventurous dessert lovers.
3. Häagen-Dazs
Häagen-Dazs is synonymous with premium, dense ice cream made from a short list of high-quality ingredients. Its rich vanilla, coffee, and dulce de leche flavors deliver a luxurious texture with minimal air whipped in. It is a go-to choice for dinner parties and for anyone who prefers simple, classic flavors executed exceptionally well.
4. Breyers
Breyers has been a household staple for well over a century, offering affordable cartons in familiar flavors. Its natural vanilla and lighter options make it a dependable choice for family dinners, birthday parties, and topping a warm slice of pie. Wide availability in every local grocery store makes it one of the easiest brands to find.
5. Turkey Hill
Turkey Hill, based in neighboring Pennsylvania, is a regional favorite throughout the Mid-Atlantic. Its creamy ice cream, iced teas, and frequent value pricing have earned a loyal following among New Jersey families. Seasonal flavors and the classic Philadelphia-style vanilla showcase its regional roots and dairy heritage.
6. Carvel
Carvel is beloved for its soft serve and iconic ice cream cakes, including the famous Fudgie the Whale and Cookie Puss characters. Its cakes have been a part of East Coast birthday celebrations for decades, and its crunchies, the chocolate crunch layer in the center, remain a nostalgic favorite.
7. Baskin-Robbins
Baskin-Robbins built its reputation on variety, famously offering a different flavor for every day of the month and many more over the years. Its scoop shops and ice cream cakes provide plenty of choices for indecisive dessert lovers and families with different tastes.
8. Dairy Queen
Dairy Queen is known for its Blizzard treats, dipped cones, and soft serve. Its drive-through convenience and summer promotions make it a quick and popular option for families on the go, especially after evening sports games and summer camp pickups.
9. Friendly's
Friendly's has long been a Northeast favorite for sundaes, Fribble shakes, and supermarket ice cream rolls. Its nostalgic flavors, such as Forbidden Chocolate and Cookies and Cream, bring back fond memories for many longtime residents.
10. Halo Top
Halo Top offers lower-calorie, higher-protein ice cream that appeals to health-conscious consumers. With a wide range of flavors and dairy-free options, it allows people to enjoy dessert while sticking to nutrition goals.
Frozen Treat Styles Explained
The Jersey Shore loves several distinct styles of frozen desserts, and knowing the differences helps you order exactly what you crave. Hard ice cream is churned and frozen solid, producing a firm, scoopable texture, with premium brands containing less air for a denser bite. Soft serve is served at a slightly warmer temperature, giving it a smooth, airy consistency perfect for cones and twists. Frozen custard includes egg yolks, which create an exceptionally rich and velvety texture. Italian ice, sometimes called water ice in the Philadelphia area, is dairy-free and refreshingly light, making it ideal on the hottest days.
Gelato, with its lower fat and slower churning, delivers intense flavor and a silky finish. Many Toms River families enjoy sampling all of these styles over the course of a summer, comparing favorites from season to season.
Tips for Enjoying Ice Cream at the Shore
Visit scoop shops and Italian ice stands in the early evening to avoid the longest summer lines. Check for seasonal and limited-edition flavors, which are often the most memorable. If you have dietary restrictions, many brands now offer dairy-free, low-sugar, and gluten-free options. For parties, ice cream cakes from Carvel or Baskin-Robbins are convenient crowd-pleasers.
Current trends include plant-based frozen desserts, globally inspired flavors, high-protein options, and nostalgic retro novelties.
Conclusion
Whether you prefer classic vanilla, a scoop loaded with mix-ins, or a refreshing Italian ice, Toms River offers access to outstanding frozen treats. These ten brands represent the very best of the area's sweet summer traditions.
