Pennsylvania's Sweet Ice Cream Heritage
Few states take ice cream as seriously as Pennsylvania. The Commonwealth's rich dairy farming tradition has produced some of America's most beloved ice cream brands, and Allentown sits right in the heart of this delicious history. Whether it is a hand-dipped cone on a warm summer evening, a pint from the grocery store freezer, or a scoop after a game at Coca-Cola Park, ice cream is a cherished part of life in the Lehigh Valley.
From historic creameries to national favorites, Allentown residents have access to an impressive variety of ice cream brands. Here is our guide to the best.
How We Ranked These Brands
We considered flavor, texture, ingredient quality, local availability, heritage, and overall popularity among Lehigh Valley residents. We gave special recognition to Pennsylvania brands that reflect the state's proud dairy legacy.
The Top 10 Ice Cream Brands in Allentown
1. Turkey Hill
Turkey Hill, made in Lancaster County, is practically synonymous with Pennsylvania ice cream. Its wide range of flavors, from classic vanilla bean to inventive seasonal options, is available in grocery stores across Allentown. Turkey Hill's reliable quality and approachable prices make it a household staple.
2. Hershey's Ice Cream
Hershey's Ice Cream, produced by the Hershey Creamery Company in Harrisburg, has been crafting ice cream for more than a century. Its products are served in many Lehigh Valley ice cream parlors and are known for rich, creamy texture and classic flavors.
3. Bassetts Ice Cream
Bassetts, founded in Philadelphia in the nineteenth century, is often described as America's oldest ice cream company. Its super-premium ice cream has a dense, luxurious texture and is a treat for anyone who appreciates old-fashioned craftsmanship.
4. Leiby's Ice Cream
Leiby's, located north of Allentown in Tamaqua, is a regional favorite famous for homemade ice cream and generous portions. Families often make the scenic drive for a classic Pennsylvania ice cream house experience.
5. Penn State Berkey Creamery
The Berkey Creamery at Penn State is a legendary destination for ice cream lovers. Made with milk from the university's own dairy herd, its ice cream is rich and full of flavor. Many Allentown residents order shipments or stock up during visits to State College.
6. Rita's Italian Ice and Frozen Custard
Founded in Bensalem, Pennsylvania, Rita's is famous for Italian ice, frozen custard, and its signature gelati layered treats. Rita's locations around Allentown celebrate the first day of spring with free ice, a tradition locals eagerly anticipate.
7. Ben and Jerry's
Ben and Jerry's is beloved for chunky, creative flavors and a strong commitment to social causes. Its pints are a freezer favorite in Allentown homes, offering indulgent mix-ins and playful flavor combinations.
8. Häagen-Dazs
Häagen-Dazs is known for its simple, high-quality ingredients and dense, creamy texture. Its classic flavors, such as vanilla bean and dulce de leche, are a go-to choice for those who prefer premium simplicity.
9. Friendly's
Friendly's has been a nostalgic favorite for decades. Its ice cream cakes, sundae cups, and half-gallon tubs remain popular for birthdays and family gatherings throughout the Lehigh Valley.
10. Breyers
Breyers has roots in Philadelphia and remains one of the most recognizable ice cream brands in America. Known for its smooth texture and wide range of flavors, including lighter options, it offers great value for everyday enjoyment.
How to Choose Your Perfect Ice Cream
Premium and super-premium ice creams contain less air and more butterfat, resulting in a richer texture. If you prefer lighter options, look for reduced-sugar, frozen yogurt, or non-dairy alternatives, which many of these brands now offer. Supporting Pennsylvania brands also helps sustain local dairy farmers.
For the best experience, visit a local parlor that serves hand-dipped scoops from these brands. Many Allentown ice cream stands open seasonally, so watch for spring openings.
Ice Cream Trends in the Lehigh Valley
Plant-based ice creams made from oat, almond, and coconut milk are growing in popularity. Small-batch and farm-to-cone ice cream is attracting customers who value local ingredients. Bold flavor experiments, including savory and international flavors, are appearing on menus, while nostalgic classics continue to hold strong.
Frequently Asked Questions
Which ice cream brands are made in Pennsylvania?
Pennsylvania is home to Turkey Hill, Hershey's Ice Cream, Bassetts, Rita's, Leiby's, and the Penn State Berkey Creamery, along with many small family-owned creameries across the state.
What is the difference between ice cream and frozen custard?
Frozen custard contains egg yolks in addition to cream and sugar, which gives it a denser, silkier texture. It is typically served fresh at a warmer temperature than traditional ice cream.
Are there dairy-free options available locally?
Yes. Many national and regional brands now offer oat, almond, and coconut-based frozen desserts, and Italian ice is a naturally dairy-free treat popular throughout the Allentown area.
When is ice cream season in the Lehigh Valley?
Many seasonal stands open in early spring and close in the fall, with peak demand from Memorial Day through Labor Day. Grocery store pints, of course, are available year-round.
Final Thoughts
Allentown is lucky to sit in a state with such a remarkable ice cream heritage. From the Pennsylvania pride of Turkey Hill, Hershey's, and Bassetts to beloved national brands, there is a perfect scoop for every taste. Grab a cone, enjoy a summer evening, and savor one of the Lehigh Valley's sweetest traditions.